• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Westminster Speed

Westminster Speed & Sound

(410) 857-5300 | CONTACT US | FINANCING AVAILABLE
  • Audio
    • BMW Upgrades
    • Ford Bronco Upgrades
    • Jeep Wrangler Upgrades
      • Jeep Wrangler Overview
      • Upgrades For Your Jeep Wrangler JL
      • Upgrades For Your Jeep Wrangler JK
    • Porsche Upgrades
    • Car Audio
    • Digital Signal Processing
    • Marine Audio
    • Motorcycle Audio
    • Stinger Heigh10 Multimedia Receiver
    • Powersports Audio and Accessories
    • Satellite Radio
    • Car Audio Repair
  • Convenience
    • Laser and Radar Detectors
    • Rear Seat Video
    • Heated Seats
    • Remote Car Starters
      • Remote Car Starters Overview
      • Remote Car Starter Models
      • Remote Starter Estimate Request
  • Accessories
    • Ceramic Paint Coating
    • Paint Protection Film
    • Windshield Protection Film
    • Lighting
    • Trailer Hitches
    • Truck Accessories
    • Truck Bed Covers
    • Truck Steps
  • Driver Safety
    • Backup Sensors
    • Backup Cameras
    • Dash Cameras
  • Security
    • Security Systems
    • IGLA Anti-Theft
  • Window Tint
    • Window Tint at WSS
    • Window Tint Estimate Request form
  • About
    • Our Work
      • Client Vehicles
      • Videos
    • About WSS
    • Why Choose WSS?
    • Customer Reviews
    • Directions
    • Install Bay
    • Showroom
    • Demo Sound Room
    • Contact Us
  • Artistry
  • Facebook

Understanding Speaker Quality: OEM Speakers

May 21, 2023 By BestCarAudio.com Leave a Comment

OEM Speaker Quality

Up to this point, we’ve explained the difference in performance between entry level, poorly designed and premium car audio amplifiers. We hope you’ve found this informative, and now it’s time we took a close look at car audio speakers. No car audio component is more crucial than speakers for reproducing music with accuracy and clarity.

This series of articles will analyze the impedance, frequency response, output capability and distortion characteristics of different car audio speakers. The goal is to give those of you who want to upgrade the clarity and performance of your audio system a clear correlation between design features, specifications and, ultimately, performance.

OEM Speaker Quality
The woven fiber cone and rubber surround of this OEM Honda Civic speaker.

Factory-Installed Honda Civic Speaker

I have a set of door speakers from a Honda Civic for our first subject. This is a woofer (no tweeter) with an effective cone diameter of 125.5 millimeters measured from the middle of the surround on one side of the driver to the center on the other side. The cone is made from a woven yellow fiber which could be of glass or aramid composition. The dust cap is formed from soft textile but is much less rigid. The speaker has a rubber surround, which lasts longer than foam.

Mechanically, the speaker has a relatively small-diameter flat linear spider bonded to a 1-inch voice coil former. There’s no cooling vent on the rear of the magnet or venting under the spider mounting ledge. The basket is formed from injection-molded, glass fiber-reinforced polycarbonate and has six deeply reinforced spokes. As is typical for an OEM speaker, the mounting flange includes a built-in spacer with an integrated gasket that will bring the speaker out near the grille in the interior door trim panel. Overall, aside from a small voice coil and lack of cooling technologies, the design offers nothing of significance to complain about.

OEM Speaker Quality
Many OEM speakers include mounting provisions that place the cone close to the interior trim panel’s grille.

Measuring Thiele/Small Parameters

Every speaker of every size can have its low-frequency characteristics modeled by a set of measurements and values summarized as Thiele/Small parameters. These measurements can be used with enclosure simulation software to predict how the driver will behave in an enclosure.

The Thiele/Small parameters quantify the driver’s suspension compliance, resonant frequency, mechanical Q, electrical Q and motor force. The information does not describe any nonlinearities in the suspension or magnetic fields or the excursion limits of the design. Far too many amateur audio enthusiasts think you can quantify the low-frequency sound quality of a speaker using enclosure simulation with Thiele/Small parameters. You can’t.

I’ll use my Clio Pocket with the added mass process to measure this information for the Honda speaker.

OEM Speaker Quality

Is there anything we can discern in terms of performance from the measured Thiele/Small parameters? The first thing we see is that the driver has a relatively high total Q (Qts) of 0.69. This will add a little resonant bump in output in the lower midbass region. It’s likely a good design trade-off for a speaker designed to be used without a subwoofer, as it will add a touch of warmth to the sound. However, in absolute terms, this will be a bit of unwanted distortion. Lastly, the predicted efficiency is relatively high at 89.04 dB SPL when driven with 1 watt of power and measured at 1 meter. This is also normal for an OEM speaker as they trade low-frequency output for increased output at higher frequencies. The ~10-gram moving mass supports this theory.

Let’s look at what the BassBox Pro enclosure simulation software predicts this driver will do in our 3-cubic-foot test enclosures. I chose this volume as it’s typically large enough to have minimal effect on the driver’s performance and should simulate how the speaker will behave in a door or rear parcel shelf.

OEM Speaker Quality
The low-frequency response of our Honda door speaker in an infinite baffle application.

As you can see from the graph above, this is more of a midrange driver than a woofer. I guessed at the 30-watt power handling based on the diminutive size of the voice coil and lack of cooling features. In terms of predictions, the driver has a -3 dB frequency of 98 hertz and would greatly benefit from being used with a subwoofer.

Measuring Driver Impedance

Part of measuring Thiele/Small parameters is to make a series of impedance sweeps. Impedance is the opposition to the flow of alternating current (AC) signals. As you can see from the graph below, the driver has a fairly tall, narrow peak around its resonant frequency of 74.7 hertz. You can also see the increase in inductance at higher frequencies as the upward trend to the right.

OEM Speaker Quality
Impedance sweep of the Honda Civic’s 6.5-inch door speaker.

We can see something else in this graph. Something has caused a noticeable resonant peak at about 700 to 800 Hz, and there are additional wiggles in the response at 2.4, 3.7 and 5.2 kHz. These are likely caused by the cone, dust cap or surround resonating. We’ll see if any of these translate into quantifiable distortion in the acoustic measurements.

Speaker Acoustic Measurements

With the driver loaded into my 3-cubic-foot test enclosure, I placed it on the floor of my lab. The microphone from the Clio Pocket is 1 yard above the top edge of the cone, where it meets the surround. We’ll use this position for all speakers going forward. We’ll begin the testing by taking frequency response measurements at increasing drive levels. While there is no specific standard, we’ll clone what Vance Dickason uses in his transducer tests in Voice Coil magazine with 0.3, 1, 3, 6, 10 and 15 volts. It’s doubtful that the driver will remain linear in output at the 10- and 15-volt levels as those values equate to 25 and 56 watts of power into a 4-ohm load. I will add a 2-volt measurement that equates to 1 watt into a 4-ohm load.

Before we get into the analysis of the speaker, we need to understand a few things about the measurements. First, the information below 30 Hz can be ignored. There is no output of 100 dB SPL at 10 Hz. Second, the dip at 130 Hz is a reflection in the room. It can be ignored as well. We know this is an acoustic cancellation because there is no dip or peak in the impedance or distortion curves. Sorry, I don’t happen to have an anechoic chamber at my disposal. In the meantime, I’ll continue to purchase lottery tickets!

OEM Speaker Quality
Frequency response of this Honda speaker when driven with a 0.3-volt RMS sweep.

Well, here’s our first look at the Honda speaker. From 160 Hz through to 1.5 kHz, the response is adequately flat given the non-anechoic characteristics of my lab. From 1.5 through to 5.5 kHz, there is a bump in the output of about 6 dB.

The black trace lower in the graph is the total harmonic distortion (THD) measured by the Clio. Let’s look at a few frequencies and make some percentage distortion calculations. From 200 through to 400 Hz, the harmonic distortion is -49 dB, equating to 0.35% THD. At 80 Hz, distortion is at 1.5%, and the significant bump in distortion around 1.3 kHz represents approximately 0.89% distortion.

Let’s sweep it again with a little more voltage – this time, the signal generator is set to 1 volt RMS.

OEM Speaker Quality
Frequency response of this Honda speaker when driven with a 1-volt RMS sweep.

The first thing to observe at this higher drive level is that the output increases linearly. All frequencies are roughly 10 dB louder. This is good because neither the suspension compliance nor the motor force has become a limiting factor. Something is happening up at 4.5 kHz that’s caused a bump in the distortion curve. Overall, though, it’s not too bad for this roughly 0.25-watt playback level.

Let’s bump things up to 3 volts.

OEM Speaker Quality
Frequency response of this Honda speaker when driven with a 3-volt RMS sweep.

In terms of frequency response, things remain nice and linear. All frequencies are once again about 10 dB louder. What isn’t so good is the harmonic distortion characteristics. A bump appears between 700 and 900 Hz at almost 2% distortion. This would be audible if not buried with other audio information. Distortion in the bass frequencies, 70 Hz, is over 3%. This 3-volt drive level equates to roughly 2.25 watts of power for a nominal 4-ohm speaker.

OK, how about 6 volts from the function generator for the next sweep?

OEM Speaker Quality
Frequency response of this Honda speaker when driven with a 6-volt RMS sweep.

A drive level of 6 volts is roughly 9 watts of power into a 4-ohm load. The graph above shows that distortion at all frequencies has increased by more than the increase in fundamental output. For example, when driven with 3 volts at 900 Hz, the THD was around 2%. Now, with 6 volts, the distortion has increased to 3%. Remember that bump we saw in the impedance graph around 800 Hz? Well, now it’s back as a peak in the distortion graph. You’d be surprised what you can learn from impedance graphs.

Last but not least, let’s feed this driver with a 10-volt sweep that equates to about 25 watts of power.

OEM Speaker Quality
Frequency response of this Honda speaker when driven with a 10-volt RMS sweep.

Though we only picked up about 3 dB more output, the distortion has increased significantly. We have 7% distortion at 800 Hz and over 3.5% at 200 Hz. If we look down in the bass region, 80 Hz is at about 10% total harmonic distortion. In short, this speaker would sound pretty bad when driven with much more than 10 to 15 watts of power and would be screaming at 25 watts.

Better Speakers Offer Better Performance

In terms of establishing a foundation for our measurements and speaker comparisons, we’ll stop here. This article will serve as a benchmark for what looked like a reasonable quality OEM speaker. We’ll test some speakers that might be better and some that might be worse over the next few months. This information should allow us to develop a correlation between design features and performance. In the meantime, if you’re shopping for new car audio speakers, drop by your local specialty mobile enhancement retailer to audition some options for your vehicle.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest

Related

Filed Under: Car Audio, ARTICLES, RESOURCE LIBRARY

About BestCarAudio.com

BestCarAudio.com is a showcase for the very best mobile electronics retailers in the world and a place to educate and inform interested consumers about existing and emerging technologies.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

OTHER RECENT POSTS

Audi S3 Speaker and Amp Upgrade

Manassas 2024 Audi S3 Speaker and Amp Upgrade

A client from Manassas recently brought his 2024 Audi S3 to Westminster Speed and Sound in hopes of … [Read More...]

Cayman Radar

2009 Porsche Cayman S Radar Detector for Columbia Client

A client from Columbia contacted our Porsche upgrade experts here at Westminster Speed and Sound to … [Read More...]

2024 Harley-Davidson Street Glide

Big Audio Upgrade for a Littletown 2024 Harley-Davidson

A client from Littletown recently dropped into Westminster Speed and Sound to inquire about … [Read More...]

Ford F-450

Outstanding Audio Upgrade for Westminster 2024 Ford F-450

A long-time client recently visited Westminster Speed and Sound to seek advice on upgrading the … [Read More...]

Civic Radar

2025 Honda Civic Radar and Laser Defense System for Owings Mills Client

A client from Owings Mills recently contacted the Westminster Speed and Sound team to ask about … [Read More...]

3M Color Stable IR Window Tint

Product Spotlight: 3M Color Stable IR Automotive Window Tint

3M is well-known for its premium-quality automotive window tint films. Our “step-up” film is the new … [Read More...]

Subscribe to Our Website via Email

Enter your email address and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Search our site with any combination of CATEGORIES, TAGS, or KEYWORDS

  • Category

  • Tags

  • Sort Order

  • Keyword

  • » Reset

Contact Us

  • This field is hidden when viewing the form

Address and Hours

202 Pennsylvania Ave Westminster, MD 21157
(410) 857-5300
Monday, Wednesday, Friday9:00 am – 5:00 pm
Tuesday, Thursday9:00 am – 7:00 pm

Directions


Get Directions to Westminster Speed and Sound

Subscribe to Our Website via Email

Enter your email address and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Copyright © 2025 Westminster Speed and Sound · Privacy Policy · Website by 1sixty8 Media, inc. · Log in · !

 

Loading Comments...